By a vote of 237-192, the U.S. House of Representatives tonight passed the conference report for the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The Senate must also approve the legislation before it can go to the president for his signature. The Senate is expected to take up the measure when it returns from the Independence Day recess the week of July 12th.
The Fourth of July deadline for enacting financial regulatory reform legislation is likely to be postponed, yet again, to the middle or end of July. The House and Senate conference committee completed its work on the Dodd Frank bill in the wee hours of last Friday morning, but the death of Sen. Robert Byrd (D-WV) and the objections of four Senate Republicans are forcing the conference committee back into session this afternoon.
Senate Democratic leadership is now struggling to find the 60 votes necessary to overcome a filibuster. Sen. Byrd was a reliable “yes” vote for the conference report, and his replacement is not expected to be sworn in for at least several weeks. The four Republican Senators who had earlier supported the Senate bill are now likely to oppose the conference report -- Scott Brown (MA), Susan Collins (ME), Charles Grassley (IA), and Olympia Snowe (ME). Sen. Brown yesterday sent a letter to Conference Chairmen Dodd (D-CT) and Frank (R-MA) explaining that he was withdrawing his earlier support of the measure due to the addition of an FDIC assessment on large banks and hedge funds that was inserted at the last minute in order to raise the $18 billion necessary to make the legislation budget-neutral. Senators Snowe and Collins have also expressed reservations about the addition of this provision, and Sen. Grassley is facing additional constituent pressure being generated around a difficult primary challenge that may cause him to reconsider his earlier support.
Of the two Senate Democrats who voted against the bill last time – Senators Russ Feingold (D-WI) and Maria Cantwell (D-WA) – Sen. Feingold continues to oppose the legislation and Sen. Cantwell remains undecided. The leaders are holding today’s conference meeting in an effort to find alternative means to pay for the shortfall and make the bill budget neutral. House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank and Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd have now proposed to raise the FDIC reserve ratio to 1.35 and divert unused TARP funds to replace the current $18 billion assessment. Of course, the new solution may well alter the support of other Senators.
Paying tribute to Senator Byrd, resolving the assessment issue, lining up the votes, and getting through significant procedural requirements in time to get members of Congress home for their Independence Day events now appears unlikely if not impossible.
With the clock ticking on a self-imposed deadline for the completion of House and Senate conference negotiations, House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) did his best impersonation of (soccer star) Landon Donovan early Friday morning, clearing a conference report that will bring Congress one step closer to passing the most sweeping financial regulatory reform legislation in nearly a century.
Capping off two weeks of publicly-televised conference committee negotiations that included a nearly 24-hour marathon session on the final day, House conferees voted 20-11 and Senators voted 7-5 to approve the measure on party lines; and provided President Obama with a critical victory prior to this weekend’s G-20 Summit in Toronto.
Below are the key issues that were resolved in conference committee on Thursday:
Derivatives
A broad array of industries, both inside and outside the financial sector, anxiously awaited the conferees’ response to controversial Senate language authored by Sen. Blanche Lincoln (D-AR) that would require banks to spin-off or “wall off” their swaps operations. After many weeks of behind-the-scenes negotiations -- including a contentious session yesterday in which House Democrats threatened to pull their support for the overall bill if the Lincoln language was included -- conferees ultimately agreed to a watered-down version that allows banks to continue trading with certain derivatives that are deemed less risky. Under the proposal offered by House Agriculture Committee Chairman Collin C. Peterson (D-MN), derivatives tied to interest rate swaps, foreign exchange swaps, gold and silver, and investment-grade credit default swaps will be exempted from the prohibition, while derivative trading related to agriculture, commodities, energy, equities, metals, and below-investment-grade credit default swaps must be walled off from a bank’s federally insured deposits.
Volcker Rule
Aside from the derivatives title, the debate surrounding the “Volcker Rule” -- or the proposed ban on proprietary trading for banks and bank holding companies -- proved to be the most contentious item on the conferees’ agenda in the final week. In the end, negotiators agreed to strengthen the Volcker Rule provisions by incorporating language offered by Senators Carl Levin (D-MI) and Jeff Merkley (D-OR) that would strip the ability of regulators to halt the Volcker Rule‘s implementation. However, in deference to the wishes of Sen. Scott Brown (R-MA)—who was one of only four Republicans to vote for the financial reform bill in the Senate— the final language would allow banks to engage in proprietary trading activities with up to three percent of their tangible common equity.
Banking Capital Standards
Another major agreement involved language authored by Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) that would limit the ability of banks to use commonly held securities known as “trust-preferred” to meet capital requirements. Although House Democrats sought a 10-year phase-in for financial institutions with assets between $15 billion and $100 billion, negotiators agreed to a five-year phase-in period for $15-$100 billion institutions and a full exemption for those with less than $15 billion.
Corporate Governance
Conferees decided to retain a Senate provision that requires publicly-trade companies to grant certain shareholders -- those owning five percent of the outstanding shares for at least two years -- to nominate and elect members of the board of directors through a proxy vote.
Levy on Banks and Hedge Funds
In order to defray the legislation’s projected $22 billion cost -- as estimated by the Congressional Budget Office -- conferees approved last-minute language that would allow the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) to levy fees on financial institutions with assets of $50 billion or more and hedge funds with managed assets of over $10 billion.
The House and Senate are expected to vote on the final conference report next week -- which is not subject to further amendment -- before sending it on to the White House for President Obama's signature and enactment into law .
After gaveling in day six of financial reform conference negotiations, House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) reaffirmed this afternoon his goal of completing conference negotiations by June 24, stating that conferees will “stay [on Thursday] until we’re finished.”
Despite a handful of controversial issues that await consideration this week—including the scope of the so-called “Volcker Rule,” heightened banking capital standards and more stringent regulations for financial derivatives—both Frank and Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd (D-CT) appear increasingly determined to wrap up conference negotiations before President Obama travels to Toronto for this weekend’s G-20 Summit. According to Frank, any potential delays would undercut the president’s leverage at the G-20 and cause further uncertainty for global financial markets. If Frank and Dodd meet their timeline it will likely set up House and Senate floor consideration of a conference report next week.
Consumer advocates secured a significant victory on Tuesday, as conferees came to a general agreement regarding the size and scope of a newly-created Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), which will be housed in the Federal Reserve and will be funded independently. An agreement also appears imminent regarding an exemption from CFPB regulation for auto dealers. Although House conferees are seeking a blanket exemption, Chairman Dodd has offered to allow the CFPB to issue rules that apply to auto dealers under the Truth in Lending Act, while the Federal Reserve would have discretion as to whether or not it enforces such rules.
Today, conferees are examining prudential banking regulation under Title 6 of the bill—which includes the Volcker Rule. Conferees are expected to consider an amendment offered by Senators Carl Levin (D-MI) and Jeff Merkley (D-OR) that would explicitly prohibit banks and bank holding companies from engaging in proprietary trading activities, as opposed to the current Senate language that provides latitude to regulators over the Volcker Rule’s implementation. In addition, Senator Scott Brown (R-MA)—who was one of only four Republicans to vote for the financial reform bill in the Senate—is lobbying conferees to include an exemption from the Volcker Rule for non-bank mutual funds and insurance companies.
With several issues leftover from last week and several more controversial ones on the agenda this week—such as the Consumer Financial Protection Agency and derivatives—it may be a challenge for the congressional conferees to finish their work by the Fourth of July. In addition to sorting out the policy issues, Congress also has to get through certain procedural hoops before the financial regulatory reform proposals become law.
July 4th is the quoted deadline, but the real deadline for Congress to finish its business on this legislation is more likely to be Thursday, July 1, or Friday, July 2, because most members will be anxious to get back to their states and districts for Independence Day events. Between now and then, several things must happen. Assuming the conferees come to a conclusion and the majority agrees to a final package, the conference committee must produce two documents:
The House will then act first and take up the conference report. The House Rules Committee will have to meet to agree to a rule for the report’s floor consideration. House rules require that conference reports must layover 72 hours, however, the Rules Committee may vote to waive that rule. If not, that could add three extra days to the process.
Once the conference report goes to the House floor, the members can vote to adopt, reject, or recommit it (to the conference committee). Assuming the House adopts the conference report, it would then go to the Senate where it is subject to debate and possibly a filibuster. Even if Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) has the 60 votes needed to invoke cloture and end the filibuster, there is a two day process for cloture plus 30 hours of post-cloture debate.
What this means is that process issues alone could take up a week’s worth of congressional time. House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) and Senate Banking Committee Chairman Chris Dodd (D-CT) are seasoned legislators who have likely factored these procedural constraints into their strategy. Financial Reform Watch predicts the Chairmen will push hard to finish the conference committee work by the end of this week or weekend, leaving next week to get through the procedural hurdles. If they are unsuccessful in bringing the conference’s work to a close by next Monday, the July 4th deadline may be in real jeopardy.
Beginning at noon tomorrow, House and Senate conferees for the financial reform legislation will return to the negotiating table for round two – this time with their attention fixed on the contentious Title 10, which props up a new regulator for consumer financial protection.
In preparation for tomorrow’s proceedings, House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) unveiled this afternoon the House’s proposals for amending the Senate language in regards to not only consumer financial protection, but also mortgage reform and predatory lending, and risk retention.
In a critical concession, Frank’s proposal would retain the Senate version’s placement of the newly-created Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) inside the Federal Reserve, a move that is likely to provoke disapproval amongst Frank’s Democratic colleagues who favor the creation of a stand-alone agency. Even Frank, himself, panned the idea of housing a new consumer regulator inside the Fed when it was first proposed in the Senate in March. But once again, Frank’s concession largely reflects the political dynamics in the Senate, where the creation of a stand-alone agency would likely unravel a fragile coalition of 60 votes required for passage.
Striking another controversial note, Frank defied long-standing White House objections by reviving language included in the House-passed version and offered as amendment in the Senate by Sen. Sam Brownback (R-KS) – but which did not receive a vote -- that would exempt auto dealers from the CFPB’s regulatory oversight. It remains uncertain whether the White House will continue to lobby against the provision during negotiations this week.
Continue Reading...When House and Senate conferees return to the negotiating table next Tuesday, they will begin consideration of arguably the thorniest issue of financial reform: the newly created consumer financial protection regulator. In addition, conferees are expected to continue debating the details of FDIC resolution authority over failing financial services institutions, along with a controversial Senate derivatives title that forces banks to spin-off their swap desks.
This afternoon, House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) and Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd (D-CT) released the following schedule for Tuesday:
Tuesday, June 22
• Pending offers and Counter-offers from Week One
• Consumer Financial Protection-CFPA/CFPB-title 10 of base text
• Predatory lending-title 14 of base text
• Risk retention-subtitle D of title 9 of base text
• Interchange-section 1076 of base text
• Access issues-titles 10, 12, and 14 of base text
As the 43 House and Senate conferees today begin debating reforms related to insurance, credit rating agencies, the thrift charter, and private funds within the financial regulatory reform bill, House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) and Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd (D-CT) announced further details of the conference committee agenda over the next couple of weeks.
Most notably, the two most contentious items of financial reform—the newly-created Consumer Financial Protection regulator and the enhanced oversight of derivatives—will be dealt with next week according to the schedule. The somewhat divisive resolution authority provisions (aimed at preventing “too-big-to-fail”) will be considered this Thursday. Below is the tentative schedule:
Week 1 (The week of June 14)
Wednesday, June 16
Thursday, June 17
Week 2 (The week of June 21)
DOWNLOAD: HR 4173 - Conference Base Text (PDF)
Jump-starting what is expected to be two weeks of conference negotiations over the competing House and Senate versions of financial regulatory reform legislation, this afternoon House Financial Services Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA) formally unveiled the first tranche of House proposals that will be considered – beginning on Tuesday at 11 a.m. -- to the base Senate bill.
Although Frank’s proposals are largely technical in nature, some present significant departures from the Senate bill. In particular, Frank is aiming to strike language added by Sen. Al Franken (D-MN) that targets the so-called practice of “rating shopping” by creating an SEC-regulated clearinghouse that would assign a rating agency for newly-created securities. Frank – who joins Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd (D-CT) in opposing the Franken proposal -- is instead offering to insert a provision that calls for a one-year SEC study to evaluate the efficacy of such a clearinghouse; and would charge the SEC with issuing recommendations to Congress.
In addition, Frank has thrown his support behind a House-passed provision that would require SEC registration and examination for private equity fund managers, contrasting with Senate language that provides for a private equity exemption. However, although both House and Senate bills require hedge fund managers to register with the SEC, Frank is proposing to broaden the Senate bill’s exemption for hedge fund managers with less than $100 million in assets to include those with less than $150 million in assets.
Frank’s proposals would amend the following titles (with links to the proposed language), which are the first titles to be considered by the conference committee on Tuesday:
The House Leaders just released their lists of conferees who will work on reconciling the House and Senate financial regulatory reform bills. See below for the complete list.
Democratic Conferees Appointed by Speaker Pelosi (CA) --
Committee on Financial Services
Barney Frank (MA), Chair, full committee
Paul Kanjorski (PA), Chair, Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Insurance, and Government Sponsored Enterprises
Maxine Waters (CA), Chair, Subcommittee on Housing and Community Opportunity
Carolyn Maloney (NY), Member of Committee
Luis Gutierrez (IL), Chair, Subcommittee on Financial Institutions and Consumer Credit
Mel Watt (NC), Chair, Subcommittee on Domestic Monetary Policy and Technology
Gregory Meeks (NY), Chair, Subcommittee on International Monetary Policy and Trade
Dennis Moore (KS), Chair, Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations
Mary Jo Kilroy (OH), Member of Committee
Gary Peters (MI), Member of Committee
Democratic Conferees on specific portions of the legislation on which their committees have jurisdiction:
Committee on Agriculture
Collin Peterson (MN), Chair, full committee
Leonard Boswell (IA), Chair, Subcommittee on General Farm Commodities and Risk Management
Committee on Energy and Commerce
Henry Waxman (CA), Chair, full committee
Bobby Rush (IL), Chair, Subcommittee on Commerce, Trade, and Consumer Protection
Committee on the Judiciary
John Conyers (MI), Chair, full committee
Howard Berman (CA), Member of Committee
Committee on Oversight and Government Reform
Edolphus Towns (NY), Chair, full committee
Elijah Cummings (MD), Member of Committee
Committee on Small Business
Nydia Velazquez (NY), Chair, full committee
Heath Shuler (NC), Chair, Subcommittee on Rural Development, Entrepreneurship and Trade
Republican Conferees Appointed by Minority Leader John Boehner (OH) --
Spencer Bachus (AL), ranking member on the House Financial Services Committee
Joe Barton (TX), ranking member of the House Energy and Commerce Committee
Sam Graves (MO), ranking member of the House Small Business Committee
Darrell Issa (CA), ranking member of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee
Frank Lucas (OK), ranking member of the House Agriculture Committee
Lamar Smith (TX), ranking member of the House Judiciary Committee
Ed Royce (CA), member of the House Financial Services Committee
Judy Biggert (IL), member of the House Financial Services Committee
Shelley Moore Capito (WV), member of the House Financial Services Committee
Jeb Hensarling (TX), member of the House Financial Services Committee
Scott Garrett (NJ), member of the House Financial Services Committee
Enter keywords:
Add this blog to your feeds or put your e-mail in the box below and hit GO to subscribe by e-mail.